Archive Pages Design$type=blogging

Shocking Report on the World’s First Gene-Edited CRISPR Babies

It seems inadequate to describe concern over the revelation that Chinese biophysicist He Jiankui used CRISPR to edit the genes of twins bor...

>
China's CRISPR twins may have superhuman intelligence.

It seems inadequate to describe concern over the revelation that Chinese biophysicist He Jiankui used CRISPR to edit the genes of twins born in late 2018 to prevent HIV as “too little, too late,” and efforts to stop further experiments of this sort as “the cat is already out of the bag.” That’s why it’s more than disconcerting to read excerpts of the report on the edits and learn that they failed. Not only that, the ethics of Jiankui and the others involved seem to be lacking or non-existent.

“The claim they have reproduced the prevalent CCR5 variant is a blatant misrepresentation of the actual data and can only be described by one term: a deliberate falsehood. The study shows that the research team instead failed to reproduce the prevalent CCR5 variant.”

The excerpts were released to the public by the MIT Technology Review which obtained a copy of the unpublished manuscript, “Birth of Twins After Genome Editing for HIV Resistance.” After noting its braggadocio tone, general lack of proof of success or any critical analysis of the process, the Review gave it to four experts in various fields and asked for their reactions. The experts — Fyodor Urnov, genome-editing scientist, Innovative Genomics Institute, University of California, Berkeley; Rita Vassena, scientific director, Eugin Group; Hank Greely, professor of law, Stanford University; Jeanne O’Brien, reproductive endocrinologist, Shady Grove Fertility – were shocked … and definitely not in a good way.

Here are some of their comments and observations (read the entire article here):

The names of the fertility doctors who treated the patients and the obstetrician who delivered the babies are missing. While this may be to hide the identities of the patients, it also prevents asking them whether they knew they were caring for the first gene-edited babies.

The team didn’t actually reproduce the known HIV mutation that the embryo editing was supposed to create to prevent HIV in the twins, so the words “success” sprinkled liberally throughout the report were, in Unrov’s words, “a deliberate falsehood.”

The father was HIV-positive, which prevented him from getting any type of treatment in China for his infertility problems, which are unrelated to the disease. Jeanne O’Brien suggests the couple may have agreed to the gene-editing as a way to get fertility treatment – or they were coerced into it or may not have even known about the editing until after the fact.

Urnov points out that CRISPR editing is inexact and it’s a “blatant falsehood” for the report to say that an edited embryo “did not show any off-target mutations” without destroying that embryo and inspecting every one of its cells.

The paper claims the China Clinical Trial Registry was informed of the experiment, but it appears that was not done until after the babies were born, which Greely says means He Jiankui “defrauded the Chinese regulatory process.”

“There is zero evidence in the manuscript supporting the essential expectation that the new forms of CCR5 would be HIV-protective. It was essential to have determined that before the embryos were implanted.”

Urnov calls the fact that the researchers didn’t test whether the HIV immunity worked before creating living human beings an “egregious violation of elementary norms of ethics and of research borders on the criminal.”

Finally, the less-than-perfect nature of CRISPR means some cells got the HIV-resistant gene edit but not necessarily all of them, and the so-called “off-target edits” could give the twins health problems caused by mosaicism — condition in which cells within the same person have a different genetic makeup. This upset Urnov the most.

“They should have worked and worked and worked until they reduced mosaicism to as close to zero as possible. This failed completely. They forged ahead anyway.”

“They forged ahead anyway.” Without regulation and with little or no concern for ethics, this seems to always happen. When human lives are at stake, this is unacceptable and, as Urnov says, borders on the criminal. Is it any wonder why He Jiankui has disappeared?

Kudos to the MIT Technology Review for obtaining this document, subjecting it to expert analysis and releasing their findings.

COMMENTS

Loading...
Name

Âm Nhạc Ẩm Thực Angela Phương Trinh Angelina Jolie Bảo Thy benh-gan Bộ Ảnh - Video Brad Pitt Bùa Ngải Bước Nhảy Hoàn Vũ cac-benh-ve-gan Cao Thái Sơn Chi Pu Chuyện chỉ có ở Trung Quốc Chuyện kỳ lạ về trẻ em Chuyện Lạ Chuyện lạ bốn phương chọn lọc Chuyện lạ cảm động về các loài vật Chuyện lạ khó tin nhưng lại có thật Chuyện lạ ở Nhật Bản Chuyện lạ thế giới khó tin nhưng có thật Chuyện lạ về các loài vật Chuyện lạ về các tài năng hiếm có Chuyện lạ về chó và mèo Chuyện lạ về du lịch Chuyện lạ về hôn nhân - vợ chồng Chuyện lạ về những kỷ lục giảm cân Chuyện lạ về sữa Chuyện lạ Việt Nam có thật Cine Cộng Đồng Mạng Công Nghệ Cung Hoàng Đạo Cường Đô La Đàm Vĩnh Hưng Đàn Ông Đặng Thu Thảo dang-mieng Đĩa Bay Diễm My 9x Điện Ảnh Diệp Lâm Anh Đỗ Mạnh Cường Đời Sống doi-song Đông Nhi Đồng Tính Động Vật Du Lịch Đức Phúc fashion Gay Giảm cân Giáo Dục Giới Trẻ Hồ Ngọc Hà Hoa Hậu Hòa Minzy Hoài Linh Hoàng Thùy Linh Học Tiếng Anh hoc-duong Hot News HotNews Hương Giang Idol Hương Tràm Huỳnh Hiểu Minh Issac Jennifer Phạm Jessica Minh Anh Kenbi Khánh Phạm Khám Phá kham-pha Khánh Hiền Khmer News khoa-hoc khoa-hoc-cong-nghe Khoảnh Khắc Lan Khuê Lazada Lê Xuân Tiền Lều Phương Anh Linh Nga Lý Hải Mai Phương Thúy Maria Ozawa Mẹo Vặt Midu Minh Hằng Miu Lê Món ngon mỗi ngày Mọt Phim Musik Mỹ Linh Mỹ Tâm News Ngô Kiến Huy Ngọc Trinh Người ngoài hành tinh Nhật Kim Anh Những chuyện kỳ quặc trên thế giới Những hiện tượng bí ẩn và khó hiểu Những người có khả năng đặc biệt Noo Phước Thịnh Ốc Thanh Vân oto-xe-may Phạm Băng Băng Phạm Hương Phẫu Thuật Thẩm Mỹ Phong cách Phượng Channel Pokémon Go Quang Dũng Sao Shopping Sĩ Thanh Sơn Tùng M-TP sport Star Sức Khỏe suc-khoe suc-khoe-gioi-tinh Tâm Linh Tâm Sự Tăng Thanh Hà Taylor Swift Thanh Hằng Thành Lộc Thanh Thảo The Face - Gương mặt thương hiệu Thể Hình The Remix – Hòa Âm Ánh Sáng the-gioi Thời Trang Thu Minh Thu Phương Thượng Ẩn Thúy Nga Tin Nổi Bật Tin Nóng Tin Thế Giới Tin Trong Nước Tình Yêu Tom Cruise Trà Ngọc Hằng Trấn Thành Trường Giang Trương Nam Thành Tử Vi tv-show UFO Ung Thư Video Việt Hương Vietnam's Next Top Model Vĩnh Thụy Võ Cảnh Võ Hoàng Yến Vũ Khắc Tiệp Vũ Ngọc Anh Vũ Ngọc Đãng xa-hoi xe xo-gan Xu Hướng - Làm Đẹp
false
ltr
item
GIẢI TRÍ SAO 24H: Shocking Report on the World’s First Gene-Edited CRISPR Babies
Shocking Report on the World’s First Gene-Edited CRISPR Babies
https://mysteriousuniverse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/china-crispr-gene-edit-twins-He-Jiankui-643x440.jpg
GIẢI TRÍ SAO 24H
https://www.giaitrisao24h.com/2019/12/shocking-report-on-worlds-first-gene.html
https://www.giaitrisao24h.com/
https://www.giaitrisao24h.com/
https://www.giaitrisao24h.com/2019/12/shocking-report-on-worlds-first-gene.html
true
5412201294335186192
UTF-8
Not found any posts VIEW ALL Readmore Reply Cancel reply Delete By Home PAGES POSTS View All BÀI CÙNG CHỦ ĐỀ LABEL ARCHIVE SEARCH Not found any post match with your request Back Home Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat January February March April May June July August September October November December Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec just now 1 minute ago $$1$$ minutes ago 1 hour ago $$1$$ hours ago Yesterday $$1$$ days ago $$1$$ weeks ago more than 5 weeks ago